Case note. Industrial Tribunal.
One act is enough for sexual harassment: Bonello v General Soft Drinks
- Court
- Industrial Tribunal
- Date of decision
- Case reference
- Industrial Tribunal case 2571/LC, decision 2019
- Jurisdiction
- Malta
- Parties
- Doris Bonello v The General Soft Drinks Company Ltd
- Bench
- Dr Leslie Cuschieri (chairman)
- Result
- Sexual harassment upheld against the employer, €2,000 compensation. Discrimination and constructive dismissal claims rejected.
Bonello is the Industrial Tribunal decision most often cited for the rule that one act can be sexual harassment in Maltese law. Its second lesson matters as much: the employer escaped blame for the remark itself, but not for the climate that kept employees from reporting.
Facts
The employee had worked for the company since 2002 and had recently been promoted to a full-time post. In November 2007, at a staff meeting run by a senior manager, she remarked that she did not know where to sit. In front of about twenty colleagues, the manager answered with a crude remark about where she could sit.
She left work that day in a state of acute anxiety and did not return. The company’s doctor visited her that evening and wrote to human resources the next day. Management reprimanded the manager and had him apologise. The company then asked her for a psychiatric report, which she never supplied. Her employment ended at the end of December 2007, and in March 2008 she filed a claim for sexual harassment, discrimination and constructive dismissal.
- The remark, at a staff meeting, in front of about twenty people.
- The manager is reprimanded and apologises. The company asks for a psychiatric report.
- Employment ends.
- Claim filed with the Industrial Tribunal.
- Decision.
Was one remark enough?
The company made three arguments: the words were vulgar, not sexual; the incident was minor; and there had been no course of conduct over several incidents.
The Tribunal rejected all three. The words were a familiar euphemism, and the sexual connotation remained even though no direct reference was intended. On repetition, the Tribunal said it might be inclined to require a course of conduct in a case of victimisation, but not in a complaint of sexual harassment. Article 29 of the Employment and Industrial Relations Act speaks of “an act” or “a request”, in the singular.
"Att ta' darba huwa fih innifsu ksur ta' din il-ligi, u mhemmx bzonn ta' pluralità."
"A single act is in itself a breach of this law, and there is no need for plurality."
Industrial Tribunal, Bonello v The General Soft Drinks Company Ltd, 27 July 2010 (our translation)
Why the employer was liable
The company’s second line of defence was that one manager’s sudden, one-off act could not have been foreseen, so the company could not be held responsible. The Tribunal partly agreed: an employer is not to blame for an unexpected single act of harassment by an employee as such. It then found that this case was different, because of the climate the company had built.
The Tribunal held that the company had not taken the measures required by regulation 12A of the Equal Treatment in Employment Regulations, which obliges employers to take effective measures to prevent harassment and sexual harassment at work. Objectively the incident was small, it said, but it had to be viewed subjectively as well, because people react differently. The complaint was upheld against the company, without prejudice to any remedy against the manager himself.
Discrimination and constructive dismissal
The discrimination claim failed. The regulations do treat harassment as a form of discriminatory treatment, but the Tribunal saw no point in stretching the law to reach the same facts twice: harassment had been dealt with as harassment. Discrimination proper needs different treatment compared with other employees, and there was no evidence of that.
The constructive dismissal claim also failed. Earlier complaints about her superiors had never been disclosed, even before the Tribunal, so it could not decide on victimisation. And she had moved straight to confrontation: she never asked for a change of role, or for the manager to be moved from over her. She asked only for compensation.
Result
The Tribunal declared that she had been sexually harassed by one of the company’s employees when the company had not taken all measures to prevent or discourage such conduct. Because no discrimination or unfair dismissal was proved, it described the company’s failure as relatively minor and fixed compensation at €2,000, payable within forty days.
Significance
Bonello answers the single-incident question for sexual harassment, and Maltese law now gives the same answer for all violence and harassment at work: article 29A, added in April 2026, defines it as conduct “whether a single occurrence or repeated”. See one incident is enough: harassment at work in Malta.
The case is just as useful on employer liability. A policy only managers have seen, and a reporting route that leads back to the people complained of, will not protect an employer. Article 29A(4) now also makes it unlawful to create or allow an environment that permits harassment. For employees, the decision is a reminder that a harassment complaint and a constructive dismissal claim are tested separately, and that leaving without raising the matter can cost the second.
Related: One incident is enough: harassment at work in Malta · Constructive dismissal in Malta · Bonello v OZO Services · Restructuring advisory
Key insights
- One act can be sexual harassment. Article 29 speaks of an act or a request in the singular, so the employee does not need to prove a course of conduct.
- An employer is not to blame for an unforeseeable one-off act as such, but it is liable if it has not built a climate in which employees feel safe to report a superior.
- A harassment policy given only to managers, and a grievance route that leads back to the people complained of, are not effective measures to prevent harassment.
- A finding of harassment does not by itself make a resignation a constructive dismissal. An employee who leaves without raising the matter or asking for any change risks losing that claim.
The law changes, so please check the current position with an advocate before acting.